Love and marriage are rocky topics on this planet of Westeros. Siblings get busy in towers, aunts and nephews rendezvous on the Slim Sea and sworn virgins run off with wildling girls.
However there may be one marital thriller that also stumps “Sport of Thrones” followers, and it includes lawfully wedded couple Tyrion Lannister (Peter Dinklage) and Sansa Stark (Sophie Turner), who will certainly see one another once more when Tyrion arrives in Winterfell with Daenerys Targaryen (Emilia Clarke) and Jon Snow (Package Harington) in Season 8.
The query stays: Are Tyrion and Sansa technically nonetheless married? And, if that’s the case, what does it imply for the ultimate final result within the quest for the Iron Throne?
First, a fast recap. Tyrion and Sansa formally mentioned “I do” in Season three on the demand of Tywin Lannister (Charles Dance), and it turns into a humiliating affair for each bride and groom. Regardless of being pressured to marry the imp of Home Lannister, nonetheless, Sansa ― the “traitor” Ned Stark’s daughter ― begins to bond with him over their shared standing in King’s Touchdown.
“The disgraced daughter and the demon monkey,” Tyrion, who’s in a dedicated relationship with Shae (Sibel Kekilli) at this level, tells Sansa. “We’re excellent for one another.”
However simply once they have all of the makings to change into an influence couple in Westeros, Tyrion is knowledgeable that his household conspired with the Freys and Boltons to savagely homicide Sansa’s brother Robb (Richard Madden) and mom Catelyn (Michelle Fairley) at what’s often known as the Purple Wedding ceremony. As soon as she learns what occurred, Sansa not trusts anybody within the capital, not to mention her Lannister husband who “swore to guard her.”
When chaos erupts following the toxic loss of life of King Joffrey (Jack Gleeson) at first of Season 4, Tyrion and Sansa are separated. Sansa shortly escapes King’s Touchdown with the assistance of Littlefinger, and Tyrion finally makes his method to Meereen to sync up with Dany following his victorious escape from jail.
Littlefinger then stupidly arranges a wedding between Sansa and the cold-hearted bastard son of Roose Bolton, Ramsay (Iwan Rheon), who’s presently ruling Winterfell. She is raped on her wedding ceremony evening, crushed and tormented — a storyline many disapprove of — earlier than she is ready to break freed from Ramsay’s clutches and discover her method again to Jon. She, with assist from the Knights of the Vale, wins again management of the North in the Battle of the Bastards and gloriously feeds Ramsay to his personal, very hungry, canine. Sansa is now Woman of Winterfell, set to guard her individuals from the military of the lifeless alongside her Stark siblings.
Which brings us again to our query concerning the standing of Tyrion and Sansa’s marriage.
In Westeros, most marriages start with a non secular ceremony involving the alternate of vows within the presence of a sacred witness, relying on the couple’s religion. A septon unites those that observe the Religion of the Seven, a priest or priestess does the identical for believers within the Drowned God or R’hllor, and a Godswood coronary heart tree is utilized by followers of the Outdated Gods. The ceremony is adopted by a feast with the bride and groom earlier than the bedding takes place, the place the wedding is consummated.
The factor is, Tyrion and Sansa by no means consummated their marriage, as he didn’t really feel it applicable to lie with a girl who was not able to be with him.
Now, Westeros is clearly a fantasy world created by A Tune of Ice and Hearth writer George R.R. Martin, but it surely does resemble medieval Europe. Martin has additionally mentioned that the Religion of the Seven is impressed by the Catholic Church, so it wouldn’t be a stretch to imagine the legal guidelines of medieval marriage considerably apply to Westeros.
That’s why we reached out to some historical past consultants to get their takes on Tyrion and Sansa’s relationship standing.
Nancy F. Cott, Jonathan Trumbull Analysis Professor of American Historical past at Harvard College, who’s an knowledgeable in marriage historical past, believes it’s all fairly easy.
“In ecclesiastical regulation, the Church would say they’re married to one another endlessly as long as they’d pledged themselves and consummated the wedding with intercourse,” Cott advised HuffPost.
One medieval historical past knowledgeable, nonetheless, offers a vastly completely different reply.
“Consummation was not crucial for a wedding,” Ruth Mazo Karras, Lecky Professor of Historical past at Trinity Faculty Dublin, advised HuffPost. “So long as each events are of age, not too intently associated to one another and all different issues that may make it a sound marriage, as soon as they’ve mentioned their vows, they’re married and so they keep married. Even when they separated, they wouldn’t be capable to marry anyone else.”
Karras believes that, in accordance with this late 12th-century regulation, Sansa and Ramsay’s marriage was an adulterous one. They have been by no means absolutely married, regardless that Littlefinger advised Roose Bolton that Sansa and Tyrion’s union was invalid as a result of it was by no means consummated.
“Westeros might need completely different legal guidelines, however to get a wedding annulled, you must present that it’s not legitimate within the first place. Saying they by no means consummated it was not ample to get it annulled,” Karras mentioned. “In sensible phrases, the pope ― and once more, that is in medieval Europe ― might need been extra keen to annul a wedding that hadn’t been consummated on different grounds, however the truth that it was not consummated was not grounds for annulment.”
One different Westerosi marriage was efficiently annulled on the present to make Rhaegar Targaryen and Lyanna Stark’s marriage legitimate. We discover out that, earlier than their wedding ceremony ceremony, the groom first secured permission from the Excessive Septon to annul his marriage to Elia Martell. Per medieval regulation, the truth that Sansa’s first marriage had not been permitted for annulment previous to her marriage to Ramsay would make the latter marriage invalid.
There’s a hitch, although. Sansa married Tyrion earlier than the Seven Gods and Ramsay earlier than the Outdated Gods — so the latter could possibly be legitimate underneath the opposite faith. It actually comes right down to what makes or who approves a reliable annulment.
In Lysa Arryn’s opinion, for instance, loss of life frees a partner to marry one other, as she tells her niece Sansa in Season 4: “You’ll be a widow quickly. They’ll execute that dwarf for murdering the king and also you’ll be free to marry Robin [her cousin].”
Stephanie Coontz, a historical past and household research professor at The Evergreen State Faculty in Olympia, Washington, advised HuffPost that the Church managed entry to marriage, divorce and remarriage within the former Roman Empire, particularly after the eighth century. However there have been situations through which the papacy was not the decision-maker.
“The place the Church was not highly effective or current, marriage was managed by non-public households, who made up their very own guidelines kind of,” Coontz mentioned. “It was not unusual for a person to take a second spouse or a concubine if his first didn’t produce an inheritor, or to repudiate one spouse for a extra fertile or better-connected one. Mother and father or different kinfolk organized the marriages of noblemen, and infrequently of commoners as nicely. Or highly effective people organized their very own, typically by murdering a rival and marrying his widow to take over his land or kingdom.”
So, by Coontz’s logic, Sansa and Tyrion might nonetheless be married if those that witnessed the preliminary union are nonetheless dedicated to it. A second ceremony might even be held to validate it.
“They’d in all probability have invented an event for an additional very public ceremony, with exchanges of items between the households, invites of different nobles, feasting, and many others,” Coontz mentioned.
Karras disagreed. “Underneath medieval canon regulation, they’d nonetheless be married and wouldn’t want any form of ceremony,” she mentioned.
“Now, in case you appeared earlier within the 12th century, there’s appreciable disagreement amongst canon attorneys about whether or not consummation is critical for a accomplished marriage,” Karras mentioned. “There may be an opinion that if in case you have one marriage that’s not consummated after which you’ve gotten a subsequent marriage that’s consummated, the one that’s consummated takes priority. So it completely depends upon which set of legal guidelines you apply.”
Medieval requirements apart, all of it comes right down to what “Sport of Thrones” showrunners Dan Weiss and David Benioff determine are the legal guidelines of the Seven Kingdoms. “This isn’t historic drama, so they might take no matter liberties with medieval canon regulation that they like,” Karras mentioned.
The writers might simply reveal that Tyrion and Sansa’s marriage continues to be legitimate, or they might land on the truth that Sansa is a single girl after Ramsay’s loss of life.
As Cott pointedly mentioned, “It’s fantasy anyway, why goal for ‘actual’ element?”
Calling all HuffPost superfans!
Join membership to change into a founding member and assist form HuffPost’s subsequent chapter